Physician-in-ordinary S.P. Botkin and Empress Maria Alexandrovna: the facts and circumstances of a courtier’s career and the specific haracter of interrelationships
Keywords:
history of medicine, court medicine, physician-in-ordinary S.P. Botkin, Empress Maria Alexandrovna, the health and illness of representatives of the Romanov dynasty, S.P. Botkin as a clinical psychologistAbstract
For eight years (1872‒1880), S.P. Botkin served as the private physician of Empress Maria Alexandrovna who suffered from pulmonary tuberculosis. The particular details of this clinical case were defined by its unique deontological aspects: a doctor, a famous professor, a recognized expert Europe-wide, was also a subject of the royal patient – his prescriptions were dependent on her wishes. Medical recommendations were often met with resistance, since due to her deep religiosity, the empress had no motivation to seek treatment. The long-term illness and the particular circumstances of the family background (the existence of the emperor’s second family) contributed to the fact that the relationship between the physician-in-ordinary and the empress was not confined to his official duties. Botkin sympathized with Maria Alexandrovna and understood that her spouses behavior was causing her distress; he was grateful for his participation in family affairs. The foundation of the empress attitude to Botkin lay in her Slavophile sentiment. It was significant that the authority of the court physician convinced society of the opinion that the royal couples separation was due to the state of the empress health. His professional enthusiasm, ability to influence the psyche and non-conformism – unusual for a royal household member – generated goodwill in the uncompliant patient, which largely ensured successful treatment. Botkins presence let the patient realize her need for care.
Downloads
References
Budko A.A., Shabunin A.V. Velikij Botkin. Serdce,
otdannoe lyudyam (Great Botkin. The Heart Given to the
People). Saint Petersburg: VMM MD RF, 2006. 302 р.
[in Russian]
Medicina i imperatorskaya vlast’ v Rossii. Zdorov’e
imperatorskoj sem’i i medicinskoe obespechenie pervyh lic
Rossii v XIX – nachale XX veka (The Health of Imperial
Family and Medical Provision of the Top Figures in Russia
in the 19th – beginning of the 20th century). Ed. G.G.
Onishchenko. Moscow: MediaPress, 2008. 327 р.
[in Russian]
Zhuravskii S.G. Dnevniki leyb-medika S.P. Botkina
kak entsiklopediya meditsiny rossiyskogo imperatorskogo
Dvora (Diaries of S.P. Botkin, Physician-in-Ordinary
to the Tzar Family, as encyclopedia of medicine of the
Russian Imperial Court). Istoriya meditsiny (History of
Medicine). 2016; 3 (2): 145–158. [in Russian]
Chicherin B.N. Vospominaniya Borisa Nikolaevicha
Chicherina: Moskovskiy universitet (The memoirs of Boris
Nikolaevich Chicherin: Moscow University). Introductiоn
by S.V. Bakhrushin. Moscow: Publishing house of
M. and S. Sabashnikovy, 1929. 280 р. [in Russian]
Tyutcheva A.F. Pri dvore dvukh imperatorov:
Vospominaniya, dnevnik, 1853–1882. Per. s nem.
i fr. (At the Court of two Emperors: Memoirs, Diary,
‒1882). Translated from German and French.
Foreword by S. Bakhrushin. Tula: Priok. kn. izd-vo,
396 р. [in Russian]
Pis’ma A.F. Tyutchevoy k m-l’ Gransi. Per. s fr. i publ.
L.V. Gladkovoy. V kn.: Rossiyskiy Arkhiv: Istoriya Otechestva v svidetel’stvakh i dokumentakh XVIII‒XX vv.:
Al’manakh. (The letters of A.F. Tuytcheva to m-lle Grancie.
[L.V. Gladkova, Trans.]. In: The Russian Archive: History
of Homeland in Evidences and Documents of the 18‒19
centuries). Vol. 18. Moscow: TRITE Studio, 2009;
‒349. [in Russian]
Dubelt L.V. Vera bez dobrykh del mertvaya veshch’. V kn.:
Rossiyskiy Arkhiv: Istoriya Otechestva v svidetel’stvakh
i dokumentakh XVIII‒XX vv.: Al’manakh. T. 6 (Faith
without work is dead). In: The Russian Archive: History
of Homeland in Evidences and Documents of the
‒19 centuries. Vol. 6. Moscow: TRITE Studio, 1995;
‒142. [in Russian]
Valuev P.A. Dnevnik P.A. Valueva, ministra vnutrennikh
del. T. 2 (1865‒1876 gg.). Redaktsiya, vvedenie,
biograficheskiy ocherk, komm. P.A. Zayonchkovskogo
(The diary of P.A. Valuev, minister of internal affairs).
Vol. 2 (1865‒1876). Ed. P.A. Zayanchkovsky. Moscow:
587 р. [in Russian]
Naryshkina E.A. Moi vospominaniya. Pod vlast’yu
trekh tsarey. Vstup. st., sost., podgot. teksta, perevod
i komment. E.V. Druzhininoy. (My memoirs. Under
the reign of the three tsars). Ed., trans., сomm.
E.V. Druzhinina. Moscow: New literary survey, 2014.
р. [in Russian]
Sheremetev S.D. Memuary grafa S.D. Sheremeteva
(The memoirs of the count S.D. Sheremetev). Ed.
L.I. Shokhin. Мoscow: Indrik, 2001. 735 р. [in Russian]
Romanova Ol’ga Nikolaevna, doch’ Imperatora
Nikolaya I. Son yunosti. Vospominaniya velikoy
knyazhny Ol’gi Nikolaevny. 1825‒1846 (The sleep
of youth. The memoirs of the Grand Duchess Olga
Nikolaevna. 1825–1846). [Elektronnyy resurs]. URL:
http://dugward.ru/library/olga_nick.html (data
obrashcheniya: 3 Noyabrya 2016).
Arseniev D.S. Iz zapisok admirala D.S. Arsen’eva
(The notes of admiral D.S. Arsen’ev). Russkiy arkhiv.
3 (11): 385‒442. [in Russian]
Shestakov I.A. Polveka obyknovennoy zhizni.
Vospominaniya (1838–1881 gody) [A half century of an
odinary life. Memories (1838‒1881)]. Saint Petersburg:
Sudostroenie, 2006. 781 р. [in Russian]
Borovikova V.N. Domashnie zapiski (Iz zhizni moey na
sluzhbe u knyazhny Dolgorukoy, Ekateriny Mikhaylovny,
a potom u svetleyshey knyagini Yur’evskoy) [Home
notes (My life in the service of princess Dolgorukaya
Ekaterina Mikhailovna, later in the service of princess
Yurievskaya)]. Na chuzhoy storone: Istoriko-lit. sb.
(On foreign soil: historical and literary collection). Ed.
S.P. Melgunov. Berlin: Vataga; Praga: Plamya, 1924:
‒87. [in Russian]
Tolstaya A.A. Zapiski freyliny: Pechal’nyy epizod iz moey
zhizni pri dvore (The notes of a lady-in-waiting. A sad
episode of my life at the court). Moscow: Entsiklopediya
rossiyskikh dereven’, 1996. 239 р. [in Russian]
Chulkov G.I. Imperatory: psikhologicheskie portrety
(The Emperors: psycological profiles). Moscow: Moscow
worker, 1991. 380 р. [in Russian]
Nikolaev V.A. Aleksandr II – chelovek na prestole:
(Alexander II – a man on the throne). Munich:
Distributed Neimanis Buchvertrieb, 1986. 630 р.
[in Russian]
Tolmachev E.P. Aleksandr II i ego vremya: V 2 kn. Kn. 1.
(Alexander II and his times). Vol. 1. Moscow: TERRA –
Knizhnyy klub, 1998. 431 р. [in Russian]
Soboleva I.A. Printsessy nemetskie – sud’by russkie
(German princesses – Russian fates). Saint Petersburg:
Piter, 2008. 412 р. [in Russian]
Sukina L.B. «Zolotoe» stoletie dinastii Romanovykh:
Mezhdu imperiey i sem’ey (The golden century of the
Romanovs dynasty: between the empire and the family).
Saint Petersburg: Piter, 2008. 332 р. [in Russian]
Manko A.V. Brachnye soyuzy Doma Romanovykh
(Alliances by marriage of the Romanovs House). Moscow:
Veche, 2010. 378 р. [in Russian]
Milyutin D.A. Dnevnik. 1879‒1881. Pod red.
L.G. Zakharovoy (Diary. 1879–1881. Ed. L.G. Zakharova). Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2010. 598 р. [in Russian]
Velikiy knyaz’ Aleksandr Mikhaylovich (Grand Duke
Alexander Mikhaylovich). Vospominaniya (Memories).
Moscow: Zakharov, 2015. 316 р. [in Russian]
Nemirovich-Danchenko V.I. Na kladbishchakh:
Vospominaniya i vpechatleniya. Sost., primechaniya
T.F. Prokopova; vstup. st. V.N. Khmary (At the
cemeteries: memories and impressions. Ed. T.F. Prokopov).
Moscow: Russkaya kniga, 2001. 544 р. [in Russian]
Radzinsky E.S. Aleksandr II: zhizn’ i smert’:
dokumental’nyy roman (Alexander II: Life and death: a
documentary novel). Moscow: 2007. 519 р. [in Russian]
Volgin I.L. Koleblyas’ nad bezdnoy. Dostoevskiy i russkiy
imperatorskiy dom (Swaying over the abyss. Dostoevskiy
and Russian imperial house). Moscow: Tsentr
gumanitarnogo obrazovaniya, 1998. 655 р. [in Russian]
Kavelin K.D. Iz dnevnika (1857 g.). V kn.: Sobranie
sochineniy K.D. Kavelina: T. 1‒4. T. 2: Publitsistika
(From the diary (1857). In: Collected edition of
K.D. Kavelin. Vol. 2). Introduction by V.D. Spasovich
and notes by prof. D.A. Korsakov. Saint Petersburg:
N. Glagolev, 1904. 1348 р. [in Russian]
Kudrina Yu.V. S vysoty prestola. Imperator Aleksandr III i
imperatritsa Mariya Fedorovna (At the height of the throne.
Emperor Alexander III and Empress Mariya Fedorovna).
Moscow: Russkiy mir, 2013. 575 р. [in Russian]
A. Fet i ego literaturnoe okruzhenie. Kn. 1. Otv. red.
T.G. Dinesman (A.A. Fet and his literary environment).
Ed. T.G. Dinesman. Literaturnoe nasledstvo. Vol. 103.
Moscow: IMLI RAN, 2008. 990 р. [in Russian]
Belogolovy N.A. S.P. Botkin, ego zhizn’ i vrachebnaya
deyatel’nost’: Biogr. ocherk d-ra N.A. Belogolovogo
(S.P. Botkin, his life and medical activity: A biographical
sketch by N.A. Belogolovy). Saint Petersburg, 1892. 79 р.
[in Russian]
Botkin S.P. Iz pervoy klinicheskoy lektsii professora
S.P. Botkina (From the first clinical lecture of professor
S.P. Botkin). Meditsinskiy vestnik. 1862. 41: 391‒393.
[in Russian]
Botkin S.P. Kurs kliniki vnutrennih boleznej i klinicheskie
lekcii (The Course of the Clinics of Internal Medicine
and Clinical Lectures). Мoscow: Medgiz, 1950. 579 р.
[in Russian]
Skorichenko G.G. Imperatorskaya voenno-meditsinskaya
(mediko-khirurgicheskaya) akademiya. Istoricheskiy
ocherk V kn.: Stoletie voennogo ministerstva [The
Imperial Military Medical Academy. In: 100th anniversary
of the Ministry of war] Vol. 9 (2) Saint Petersburg, 1902.
р. [in Russian]
Balakirev M.A. Perepiska M.A. Balakireva s
V.V. Stasovym (Correspondence of M. A. Balakirev with
V.V. Stasov). Foreword and commentary by V. Karenin,
Introduction by G.L. Kisilev. Moscow, 1935. 276 р.
[in Russian]
Suvorin A.S. V ozhidanii veka ХХ. Malen’kie pis’ma
(1889‒1903) [Awaiting the 20th century. Small letters
(1889–1903)]. Moscow: Algoritm, 2005. 1021 р.
[in Russian]
Meshchersky V.P. Moi vospominaniya. (My memories).
nd ed. Moscow: Zakharov, 2003. 860 р. [in Russian]
Zakharova L.G. Aleksandr II i mesto Rossii v mire.
(Alexander II and the place of Russia in the world). Novaya
i novejshaya istoriya. 2005; 2: 164‒193 [in Russian]
Paperni V. Antimeditsinskie motivy v romane L’va Tolstogo
«Voyna i mir» (Antimedical motives in Leo Tolstoy’s novel
“War and Peace”). TSQ. 2014. 47. Winter: 154‒173.
[in Russian]
Unkovsky M.A. M.E. Saltykov i ego sem’ya po
rasskazam moego ottsa i lichnym vospominaniyam.
V kn.: M.E. Saltykov-Shchedrin v vospominaniyakh
sovremennikov. (M.E. Saltykov and his family). In:
M.E. Saltykov-Shchedrin in recollections of his
contemporaries. Vol. 2. Ed. S.A. Makashin. Moscow:
Khudozhestvennaya literatura, 1975; 313‒324.
[in Russian]
Pavlova S.V. Iz vospominaniy (The memories). Novyj mir.
; 3: 97‒144. [in Russian]
Arsenev D.S. Iz vospominaniy general-ad’’yutanta,
admirala D.S. Arsen’eva 1876‒1878 gg. (From the memories
of adjuntant general, admiral D.S. Arseniev 1876‒1878).
Russkiy arkhiv. 1911; 12: 567‒635. [in Russian]
Valuev P.A. Dnevnik. 1877‒1884 (The Diary.
‒1884). Ed. by V.Ya. Yakovleva-Bogucharsky
and P.E. Shchegolev. Petrograd: Byloe, 1919; 311.
[in Russian]
Gorbunova Yu.A. 1874‒1878 gg. v Livadii. Zapiski
Yu.A. Gorbunovoy (Prodolzhenie). (1874‒1878 in
Livadia. The notes of Yu.A. Gorbunova). Nasha starina.
; 11: 993‒1008. [in Russian]
Bokhanov A.N. Imperatritsa Mariya. Istoricheskoe
zhizneopisanie (Empress Maria. Historical biography).
Moscow: Progress-Pleyada, 2007. 518 р. [in Russian]
Spisok grazhdanskim chinam pervyh chetyrekh klassov
(The list of civil ranks of the fourth class). Saint Petersburg,
631 р. [in Russian]
Melega V. Imperatorskaya familiya v Krymu (The imperial
family in the Crimea). Russkaya starina. 1916; 11:
‒319. [in Russian]
Botkin S.P. Pis’ma S.P. Botkina iz Bolgarii (The letters
of S.P. Botkin from Bulgaria). Saint Petersburg: Tip.
Stasyulevicha, 1893. 374 p. [in Russian]
Kropotkin P.A. Zapiski revolyutsionera (The notes of
a revolutionary). Moscow: Golos truda, 1920. 399 p.
[in Russian]
Bertenson V.B. Za 30 let (Listki iz vospominaniy) (For 30
years. Sheets of recollections). Saint Petersburg: Tip.
T-va A.S. Suvorina «Novoe Vremya», 1914. 283 p.
[in Russian]
Chudnovskii S.L. Iz dal’nikh let (otryvki iz vospominaniy).
(From long ago. Memories). Byloe. 1907; 9: 278‒295.
[in Russian]
Sokolov N.I. Istoriya bolezni Sergeya Petrovicha
Botkina (The medical case of Sergey Petrovich Botkin).
Saint Petersburg: Tip. Stasyulevicha, 1890. 22 p.
[in Russian]
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
You are free to:
- Share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format for any purpose, even commercially.
- Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.
- The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as long as you follow the license terms.
Under the following terms:
- Attribution — You must give appropriate credit , provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made . You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
- No additional restrictions — You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that legally restrict others from doing anything the license permits.
Notices:
You do not have to comply with the license for elements of the material in the public domain or where your use is permitted by an applicable exception or limitation .
No warranties are given. The license may not give you all of the permissions necessary for your intended use. For example, other rights such as publicity, privacy, or moral rights may limit how you use the material.
